Monday TV Ratings 4/21/25: America’s Most Wanted Abysmal in Return, Poppa’s House and NCIS Rebound, American Idol Up from Last Monday [+ Analysis]

Ratings Analysis: In its Fox return, America's Most Wanted (0.12) proved to be an even weaker option than Rescue: HI-Surf. The long-running reality series dropped significantly from the season finale of Extracted (0.19, +0.01) and barely cleared the one-million mark in total viewership. The Neighborhood (0.35, +0.02), Poppa's House (0.31, +0.05), NCIS (0.39, +0.13), and NCIS: Origins (0.26, +0.03) all climbed higher on CBS, with NCIS in particular growing substantially. American Idol (0.44, +0.04) and Paradise (0.14, +0.02) were both up from last week's installments on ABC. NBC aired a clip show of The Voice (0.20) and a rerun of Law & Order: SVU (0.08). All American (0.06, +0.01) ticked up on the CW. Key: (P) = premiere. (R) = repeat. (F) = finale.

Time	Show	18-49 Rating	18-49 Share	Viewers (mil)	Network
8 PM	American Idol	0.44	6	4.19	ABC
	The Neighborhood	0.35	5	4.05	CBS
	The Voice (Clip Show)	0.20	3	2.57	NBC
	Extracted (F)	0.19	3	1.44	Fox
	All American	0.06	1	0.33	CW
8:30 PM	Poppa's House	0.31	4	3.48	CBS
9 PM	NCIS	0.39	5	5.80	CBS
	America's Most Wanted (P)	0.12	2	1.10	Fox
	Trivial Pursuit (R)	0.03	0	0.20	CW
10 PM	NCIS: Origins	0.26	4	3.89	CBS
	Paradise	0.14	2	1.40	ABC
	Law & Order: SVU (R)	0.08	1	1.29	NBC

Cable Highlights:

Show	Network	18-49 Viewers	Viewers (mil.)
NBA Playoffs: Pistons v. Knicks	TNT	0.95	2.95
NHL Playoffs: Canadiens v. Capitals	ESPN	0.27	0.90
Jesse Watters Primetime	Fox News	0.22	3.57
Gutfeld!	Fox News	0.17	2.89
Hannity	Fox News	0.17	2.79
NHL Playoffs; Blues v. Jets	ESPN2	0.12	0.37
Spring Baking Championship	Food	0.09	0.70
The Rachel Maddow Show	MSNBC	0.07	2.15
NewsNight	CNN	0.06	0.55
The Source with Kaitlan Collins	CNN	0.06	0.50
MLB: Padres v. Tigers	FS1	0.06	0.31
Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell	MSNBC	0.05	1.61
Anderson Cooper 360	CNN	0.05	0.52
Inside with Jen Psaki	MSNBC	0.03	1.05
Silos Baking Competition	Food	0.02	0.21