Each week, I take a look back at a pilot from the 2011-12 season, first reviewed on my blog during that season. This week, I am looking at NBC's failed British import Prime Suspect!
The Details:
Premiered: September 22, 2011 on NBC
Starring: Maria Bello, Brian F. O'Byrne, Kirk Acevedo, Peter Gerety, Tim Griffin, Damon Gupton, Kenny Johnson, Joe Nieves and Aidan Quinn
Based on: the British Series "Prime Suspect"
Developed by: Alexandra Cunningham
What I Thought Then:
"Many critics have said this is an outdated plot and to some degree, they're right, but there's still things to like about this show."
"Maria Bello has a lot of strong points in the pilot. She is a take-charge woman and that shows from the very first scene in the taxi."
"This would have had a lot more power and bite if it had premiered 20 years ago."
"This has the potential to be a good cop show but it shouldn't try to present itself as shattering glass ceilings because other shows have already done that."
What Others Said:
"It's arresting and criminally entertaining." - Aaron Riccio, Slant Magazine
"The best new crime drama of the fall season doesn't necessarily have to be an original idea. It just has to have the right people in place." - Ed Bark, Uncle Barky
"It feels awfully dated, except when Bello takes matters in her own hands to keep things fresh." - Matt Roush, TV Guide
"The show has to get beyond plot predictability and one-dimensional characterization if it's going to survive." - David Wiegand, San Francisco Chronicle
"The only suspects of interest in this crime series are the producers and writers who threw this hapless business together, and called it Prime Suspect." - Dorothy Rabinowitz, Wall Street Journal
What I Think Now:
I was not, and still am not, familiar with the successful British Helen Mirren series this is based on. I know it was a big hit that ran for many years but this is IP at its worst instincts. The character from the British series is not a wholly recognizable character anywhere like Fred Flintstone or Betty Boop. It is a very specific character that was fully tied to Helen Mirren's performance and style. And that includes her physical appearance. So dressing Maria Bello like Mirren while trying to move the show to New York City begged the question "why do this at all?" Why not just put Bello in a cop drama that they could start from scratch. And therein lies the problem with IP. Because it's so much easier to sell even when the landscape is littered with remakes that don't do well. And while I don't doubt that sexism is in the workplace, especially in a city police department, the behavior of the other cops in this pilot (including guest star Jason Beghe a few years before Chicago PD) was so littered in stereotypes of sexist veteran NYPD officers to the point that they seemed almost cartoonish. Even when the show tried to redeem them at the end, it wasn't enough. They needed to do some actual character work that they either didn't seem interested in or didn't have time for. The case of the week in the pilot was fine. Bello was fine. This was mostly forgettable.
What Happened to the Show:
NBC was in shambles heading into Fall 2011. They were still recovering from the Jay Leno fiasco, especially in the 10pm hour and while they successfully launched The Voice in Spring 2011, it wasn't back for the fall and their scripted slate was struggling mightily. They had a Thursday comedy lineup from 8-10pm that was critically acclaimed and while it wasn't delivering huge numbers, it was one of the more successful nights for the network. The network tried to get back in the prestige drama on Thursdays at 10pm that had been the norm for decades with Hill Street Blues into LA Law into ER and they thought Prime Suspect could do the trip. The British series it was based on was beloved and Maria Bello was a well-respected actress (who had spent a short time on ER among other things). Despite a lot of promotion and solid reviews (65 on Metacritic), the series premiered to dismal numbers (6.8 million viewers and a 1.8 demo, losing a huge amount of its lead-in from new comedy Whitney). NBC had bigger worries though with The Playboy Club instantly bombing on Mondays. NBC preached patience with Suspect and even ran some repeats on Mondays after Playboy was cancelled. But the ratings didn't improve. NBC shut down production on the show in November as the show finished its original 13 episode order and sent to the scrap heap.
Final Episode: January 22, 2012
Episode Count: 13
Where to Watch: Peacock
I'm excited to be contributing to The TV Ratings Guide! You can read my regular work at Benjamonster's TV!


